13 Reasons to Not Watch 13 Reasons Why


13 Reasons Why I Hate 13 Reasons Why
(HEAVY SPOILERS)


1. It Glorifies Suicide.

In Season One of 13 Reasons, we're introduced to Hannah Baker, a girl who committed suicide and left recorded messages behind for the people that she deemed responsible for her suicide. The whole season has two timelines: one that follows her through the events that led her to commit suicide, and a secondary storyline where her almost-but-not-quite boyfriend Clay is listening to the tapes and responding over a period of multiple months. 
The events in the secondary timeline, the one after her death, are staged like a soap opera: it's a disgusting cesspool of dramatic "he said, she said". Even after this tragedy, the teens involved do not seem to be changed. The same ridiculous culture persists, becomes even more flagrant, even. It is not a tale of healing, it is a tale about a girl who managed to upset her whole environment in an exciting way, by pitting her friends against each other. It's seen almost like a twisted but positive thing - Hannah gets exactly what she wants. It creates this idea that suicide is... not that it's good, but that it's almost cool? Like it's a means to an end.

2.  It's Graphic. Too Graphic. 

The great controversies of Season One were two scenes: One, in which Hannah is raped onscreen in a hot tub by Bryce, or as I like to call him, Evil. The second, in which Hannah commits suicide onscreen. Not ambiguously at all. There are shots of her cutting into her own arms. 
Now, I am lucky. I have never experienced extreme sexual assault, nor have I ever had suicidal thoughts. But despite that, both of these scenes made me sick and panicky. I had to shut down my computer and watch them with my family, later. (We were all watching the series, just not together. None of us were comfortable watching these scenes alone.)
One of my friends who has experienced depression confided in me and said "13 Reasons Why is honestly so toxic. Watching those scenes onscreen made me feel panicked. I couldn't breathe." (Don't worry, I got their consent before using this quote).
Suicide needs to be represented - just as rape needs to be represented - so people know how to get help. but there's nothing like that here. It's all just a plot device, and it's much more dramatic (and profitable) to have a girl be raped and never be able to recover than to have a healthy showing of how to recover.

3. The Issues aren't Handled with Care.

Rape, suicide, bullying, homophobia, and school shootings are all addressed throughout 13 Reason's two seasons. I have problems with the way all of them factored into the story. 
I already discussed suicide. Then bullying: not one single person stands up for Hannah or anyone else. All the girls are shown as petty, catty, and self-destructive while the guys are shown as massive brutes with the exception of a few, who are marketed as creepy or weak. There is approximately zero nuance or gray area. All of these characters are low-key sociopaths, and it's disturbing.
The one lesbian character's storyline is never fleshed out. We're left hanging. Not to mention Courtney is a terrible person. It's a mess. As for Tony, and his gay plotline: it's nearly nonexistent. 
Rape is in both seasons. First, there is Jessica: raped by Bryce while her boyfriend sat by and allowed it to happen. Then there's Hannah, of course, another of Bryce's victims. Then in the second season, Tyler. He's raped by Monty in the school bathroom. All of these scenes are handled extremely poorly in my opinion, and they aftermaths of them are once again almost cartoonishly bad. 
Jessica is lied to by all of her friends, including her then boyfriend Justin, and when she (and we alongside her) find out, a huge emphasis is put on Justin. His heartbreak becomes the focus, their relationship drama the priority. Later in season two she has one or two scenes where she shows signs of PTSD, but there's a huge lack of content in that department. The aftermath of Hannah's rape is her suicide, so yeah: not handled well. Then Tyler's - well. Tyler's leads us into the next reason.

4. The Ending of Season Two.

For those that haven't and don't intend to watch it (such as myself) I've done some research. Tyler, after his rape, snaps. He buys an assault rifle and heads to school, ready to commit a school shooting. There, he is stopped by Clay who manages to "talk him down" and get him into a getaway car, leaving Clay standing alone by the curb, a whole ASSAULT RIFLE in his hands as the police begin to arrive. And then the season ends. 
I have so many issues with this. First: it perpetuates the stereotype that mass shootings are most often committed by those who have been bullied or oppressed in some way. 
According to CNN:
- 64% are committed by white people (almost exclusively men)
- 16% are committed by black people (almost exclusively men)
- 9% are committed by people of Asian descent (almost exclusively men)
- Latinx and Native Americans did not even factor in, the numbers were so insignificant
- 90% of all murders (not just mass shootings) are committed by men
- 61% are committed by someone who has been diagnosed with a mental illness (this does not factor in those suspected of having a mental illness)
In reality, shooters are not often victims: most of the time, they're aggressors. To make Tyler have complex reasons for his unforgivable act of violence humanizes the shooters we see in real life. It projects this idea that if we learn more about them, we might find answers. Sometimes (in fact, most times) that's just not the case. 
Additionally, Clay puts himself at risk and actively helps Tyler escape the police. This isn't an appropriate response to that situation, and the whole scene is so clearly placed there for dramatic effect that it makes me sick. 
Oh, did I mention that the second season was released the same day of the Santa Fe shooting?

5. Clay. 

Sorry, bud. But you're kind of the worst character ever. 
In the book Clay listens to the tape in one night. He responds like a normal human being. But in this show, not so much. In between tapes he seeks people out and confronts them when he doesn't even know the whole story yet, creating unnecessary drama and only stoking the hellfire that is this whole show. 
Additionally, the show creates a narrative around Hannah and Clay's great love story. What love story? There literally isn't one. They never dated. They may have gotten together eventually if Hannah had lived, but they play it off in the show as though if Clay had dated Hannah, she would have lived. Problems solved, Clay loves me! At Hannah's funeral in the second season, Clay (for some reason) has a speech, despite never really being that close to Hannah in life. 
And the first this he says is "She was funny, and smart, and moody, and maddening. And beautiful. And I loved her." Okay, what? You guys talked a few times when she was alive. Almost made out once. There was admittedly sexual tension for days. 
But you never dated. You never even kissed. And even if you had, I doubt that would have (realistically) stopped Hannah from doing what she did. But the show doesn't talk about that at all. They make Clay into this awkward knight in shining armor who's coming to avenge Hannah or something. It's really gross, and I hate it. 
And there's an uncomfortable amount of mansplaining that comes out of his mouth, and a whole bunch of really bad advice. It's just painful to watch him as a character, because he's so clearly a creation of some show runner who doesn't really know what he's talking about, but sure thinks he does. Clay is mansplaining incarnate. Oh god.

6. The Quality. 

It's just cheesy, guys. Ignoring all the problematic things, it's just bad writing. I'm sorry. None of the characters feel real, just like barely fleshed out plot devices. They're all stand-ins for different social issues. Jessica is PTSD, Justin is Addiction, Bryce is Rape, Tyler was Stalking and now he's School Shootings, Hannah is Suicide, Courtney is Homophobia, Alex was Depression and now he's Amnesia, Zach is the Consequences of Inaction. The show feels like it's trying to tackle everything at once. Tony is the only one who feels mildly real, and even he barely works. It's tragic.
And again, the thing reads like a soap opera. The number of long speeches with no real meaning but a lot of pretty words is deeply concerning to me. 
Please hire some better writers. The show isn't even well written trash. It's just trash.

7. The Complete Lack of Effective Law Enforcement. 

Where are they? The police are nowhere. They're never contacted, and when they are, nothing good happens. It's a mess. The jury rules Bryce not guilty despite overwhelming evidence that he is, in fact, guilty. All he's got is his own testimony and the fact that Hannah once bullied someone in her past. That doesn't mean that everyone is lying about Bryce's history of sexual assault. 
After Hannah's debacle the police aren't anywhere to be seen either. Giant, loud, alcohol filled parties at Bryce's and you're telling me that absolutely nobody called the police? Sure. Oh, Tyler has a gun. You know who I should definitely not contact or help? The police. 
What is happening? Why? Is there some reason the show appears to be making the police into the enemy?
All these terrible things that happen are simply never dealt with, and that translates into a very bad guide for people going through these same things. it further perpetuates the idea in many teenagers minds that the police are useless, and thus not a reliable resource. 
Now, I'm the last person to say our legal system is perfect. It's not. But it still serves a purpose, and its not all the same. There is usually a path to get help.

8. The Characters.

I've talked about this a bit already, but the characters are deplorable. They're all guilty. Every single one of them. Some are psychopaths (Bryce, Monty) and the rest are sociopaths. There isn't a single one of them that I wouldn't like to burn. All of them are just chock full of damaging stereotypes and unfulfilled potential.
The complete hive mind of the high school is disgusting to watch and can really affect how depressed teens see those around them, even their friends. The show doesn't show any real solidarity outside of Clay, and I already have a whole section here about his problems. 
It pits everyone against each other in an almost comical, reality show fashion. It's not true to life in the slightest, yet it markets itself as bringing awareness to a "real life issue." When every single character is so fake, the show lacks that aspect of realism needed to have a productive conversation about these kinds of issues. How can it be dealing with these complex psychological issues when they can't even develop realistic characters? 

9. It Shows Suicide as a Form of Revenge.

Hannah's suicide is painted as an escape route from the hell that was her life; an endless stream of bullying and disappointment. Her opening on the tapes is aggressive, almost "you ruined my life, but you can't touch me now. Now, you should suffer like I did."
And boy. Hannah gets exactly what she wants. Everyone's life is ruined. 
The show is basically about Hannah using suicide as a weapon to get revenge on those who she blames for it, almost like afterwards she's vindicated, as though she was going through this alone and could only be understood in death. She's not vindicated though - she's still just dead. 
This sends such a harmful message to people who are going through a rough time in their lives. It sends the message that it will never end, that they have no more option, that people are forcing them to do it, that this is a way to be heard. They want to be like Hannah: Tragic heroes who are untouchable. 

10. Literally Everyone Told Them it was a Bad Idea.

Before releasing 13 Reasons, the producers talked to psychologists. Correction, they talked to two. And then they also listened to their staff who had gone through traumatic experiences (including Selena Gomez and Nick Sheff). 
After the show aired, both of the psychologists admitted that more could have been done to keep it safe for those watching. Right before it aired, Dr. Dan Reidenberg of the Suicide Awareness Voices of Education was invited to watch the series and critique it. He stated he had problems with the glamorizing, sensationalizing, memorializing aspects of the series, the violence and brutality, the rape; the failure of reaching out for help, the lack of options and alternatives to Hannah’s suicide,  and the revenge plot. Had he been involved earlier, he said, he would have advised producers to do "everything that they can to reduce the risk of copycat behavior and suicide contagion by following safe messaging standards."
Oh yeah, because there are safe messaging standards about portraying suicide. 
According to The American Foundation for Suicide Prevention:
- More than 50 studies have found that increased exposure to suicide can increase the likelihood of suicide in vulnerable individuals
- risk increases when the suicide is explicitly shown or the method is described, or when dramatic/graphic images are used and repeated/extensive coverage sensationalizes or glamorizes a death
- including location of death or grieving friends and family can encourage vulnerable individuals that their actions will gain them what they view as positive attention
- saying that it "came out of nowhere" or was "without warning" discourages people from keeping on guard for the signs and perpetuates the idea that suicide is not preventable, when in most cases there are clear warning signs and the person could have gotten help
- making clear that there is more than one cause to suicide, and it is not often just down to one issue like "bullying" but many complex problems, can encourage people to preserve through harder times rather than giving up hope
- always be certain to include multiple resources and impress upon the viewer that suicide is never a valid option
Yeah, I don't think 13 Reasons Why followed any of those suggestions. Well done, guys. Selena Gomez and Nick Sheff both supported the suicide and rape scenes, saying they were emotionally healing to write and film, and it felt wrong to not include them. But the reality is that feeling and facts are two whole different worlds, and they didn't do their research. They may not have meant any harm, but their creation has spiraled beyond that.

11. Hannah.

Hannah was extremely problematic. She was portrayed as a tragic hero. She certainly faced very real trials and tribulations, do not get me wrong.  But she was extremely two dimensional. She is extremely affected by petty drama and she seems to have this part of her character that is just waiting for her cute coworker to come and solve her problems for her. 
There is no discussion within herself about why she's really doing this. She pushes all of the reasons she's sad and mad and hurt onto others. She doesn't really look into any other options besides Mr. Porter. She's expecting a lot from a school counselor. She does not talk to her parents. She does not discuss anything with anyone. 
Hannah Baker was a great opportunity to have a real look at depression, to try to represent some of the thoughts going on in her mind and show how the people around her should respond. But instead she becomes a petty teenaged girl, just like every other character in the series. 
The series is a basic teen drama, but it's got this air of self importance, as though it's really tackling the real issues. But their main character, the girl who commits suicide, doesn't really display the typical qualities of a person who commits suicide. Usually it's a myriad of things: bullying, rough family life, and above all: mental illness. 
The only thing discussed in Hannah's story is bullying, which makes sense: mental illness is internal. It's a lot harder to build a teen drama around. But bullying? That's a piece of cake. All they had to sacrifice was the integrity of their main character. 

12. The Parents. 

Again. What are y'all doing? Every parent in this series seems to completely lack the ability to understand what's going on with their kids. Half the first season Clay's parents desperately try to reconnect with him. Justin's mother allows him to be abused by her boyfriend. Bryce's parents... Who even knows where they are, to be honest. Jessica's dad just seems out of touch. 
Heck, these kids are waking up with nightmares (Clay) , coming home with god-awful bruises (Alex), and getting rocks thrown through their window every couple of days (Tyler) and none of their parents have any kind of questions about that? 
Through all of this, the parents basically do nothing. They just sit back and enjoy the show. 
Now I understand that in real life, not everyone has a parent who is invested in their life. But if this show is going to deal with suicide safely, parents need to be seen at the very least as potential avenues to safety. But no - instead they are set up like they're so disconnected from their kids that they could never understand. 
It sends the message that struggling teens and kids can't speak to their parents because they're out of touch, and they'd be no help anyways. That's not useful, that's damaging.

13. The Contagion.

Here it is. The big one. 
13 Reasons Why actively hurts the people it claims to be helping to protect. As I mentioned earlier, it violates a ton of AFSP's guidelines for helpful portrayals of suicide and completely misses the mark with the issues themselves anyways. 
But this translates into the real world. As tragic as it is, suicide has been proven to be contagious. Publicity surrounding suicide has been proven to have a direct link to a rise in suicide and suicidal thoughts, especially in young people, who are more vulnerable to media messages. 
The publicity around suicides, especially those of celebrities (or dramatized characters), can be attractive to people who are already vulnerable or feel like they have nothing to live for. Seeing someone get so much attention can be encouragement. 
The problem lies in this: Suicide is often inadvertently presented as a simple solution to life's problems, and since it's always portrayed like that, people begin to actually see it that way. 
And so, after a bout of publicity, Google searches pertaining to suicide methods rise alongside actual suicide rates. 
13 Reasons Why's biggest problem is that it doesn't understand it's own influence. It just keeps preaching. The people that produce it are trying to help, but they're not really educated about the issues, and it shows. 
The road to hell is paved with good intentions. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Work on Your Lyrics, Rihanna

The 1967 Chevy Impala

vines that cured my anxiety over my term paper