Boyfriend Culture


What I like to call "boyfriend culture" is everywhere. It's whispered in the hallways, during late night sleepovers, and of course, shouted loudly from every television screen, everywhere. What is boyfriend culture? It's exactly what Lisa Ling talked about in this quote from the documentary Miss Representation. It's the idea that girls aren't complete without a boyfriend.
I hear people complain about their single status all the time. I'm not going to exclude myself from that - in the past I've been super insecure because I've never had a relationship.
A huge deal is made out of any kind of relationship drama. There's a ton of "he likes her, she likes him" talk that's constantly circulating, and it honestly makes it so much harder to date. Suddenly everything you do that concerns interacting with him is huge. My favorite example of this is that in middle school, some of my friends freaked because I touched the same paper that a guy they thought I'd be cute with touched.  It was another level. Again, not excluding myself from this - there's something exciting about that kind of talk, and I've participated in it on multiple occasions.
All I have to do is open Instagram, and suddenly I'm face to face with my own singleness. Couples photos, memes about being single (and how tragic it is), adorable promposal videos, boyfriend/girlfriend tags, other cute videos, the random text post about some cute things someone's boyfriend did for her. It's hard not to feel left out.
In the end, it all comes back to the fact that this is what the media tells us we're meant to be doing. Miss Representation mentioned that the majority of movies with a female lead were romcoms or chick flicks. One sec, let me just write an award winning chick flick.
First, our protagonist, Emily Basicname. She's an office worker, but she's a lil quirky, you know? Her best friend, Sarah Comicrelief has informed her that she's way too single, and she needs to live it up! (Bonus points if Sarah Comicrelief has a boyfriend. Extra bonus if they're married.)
Then Emily Basicname meets Chad Hotguy. (Bonus points if  Emily fell over herself or something when she saw him. Maybe spilled coffee on herself or him in her distraction, just like a real woman would.) Chad Hotguy is just perfect, you know?
But something is keeping them from being together! Maybe they got off on the wrong foot after she spilled that coffee, who knows. But don't fear! Emily will get her man through a combination of her quirkiness, her helplessness, and some random chance events that have very little to do with communication at all.
It will all culminate in a beautiful kissing scene either in the rain, or at sunset, or in some random field somewhere, right after Chad finally asks her out, probably saying she's beautiful and unique or something else along those lines. And then, bam. They live happily ever after. Sarah says she just knew it all along that they were perfect for each other.
Wow, realistic.
And the thing is that it's not realistic at all, but it creates some really unrealistic standards. I can't expect a guy to come out here and spend all his time, money, and strength to try to woo me, and he can't expect me to always say yes, to be there for him, to be the doting, docile girlfriend. It's not how life is.
There's this whole image that's created for girls about who we're supposed to be. We're supposed to attract men, according to the media. We're supposed to be helpless. We're supposed to care only about makeup and clothes and our outward appearance. We're supposed to fight over guys and have some kind of Mean Girls-esque hierarchy that eliminates those that are the worst at being objects.
There's this culture that just exists, even in the most feminist of circles, like a stain that you can't seem to get out, no matter how many times you scrub at it. It shows up in the most harmless of jokes, like the fact I know literally nothing about the application of makeup (Do we really need forty different creams? Why are there so many powders? Why do I have to put four separate colors plus glitter on my eyes to get the look? What is the point of lipstick? It just gets everywhere and never comes out. Don't even get me started on mascara and eyeliner. You're basically almost putting in in your eye sometimes! How does any of it actually work? Why are we forced to put makeup over our pimples when that just suffocates them and makes them heal even slower?), which has been an inside joke in my friend group since elementary school.
I was told by a female classmate when I was about 8 that I shouldn't wear skirts because they made me look like I had chicken legs. I still feel uncomfortable wearing skirts today. I was told by a guy in my Spanish class that I looked sick once when wearing contacts because I hadn't put concealer under my eyes. (He also added that I didn't need to change myself, and that I was beautiful with glasses. No duh, honey, I just wanted to wear contacts today. Don't hurt yourself thinking about it.) My elementary and middle school bully used the way I dressed in 5th and 6th grade to hurt me sometimes (look, y'all can fight me, but floor length skirts with crocs was a look that I 100% slayed).
I've heard the term "but no one will like you if you look like that" far too many times and far too casually. My brother can walk into church wearing basketball shorts but I have to be wearing a dress or nice pants. Shorts are apparently illegal, as my mom once made me go change after I tried to wear shorts to church in the summer.
The makeup industry sucks. So does the clothes industry, the underwear industry, and the film industry. The worst part is that they pretend like they're doing it to help women feel empowered.
"Wear this makeup, and you'll feel powerful (because you can attract men because you won't be ugly anymore)."
"Wear these clothes, and you'll be powerful (because you can attract men because you won't be ugly and fat anymore)."
"Wear this underwear, and you'll feel powerful (because you can attract men because you're body won't be ugly anymore)."
"Watch this movie, and you'll feel powerful (because the main character is super basic yet she became attractive to men, so so can you)."
Of course, these things can be empowering. I've felt on top of the world after seeing a film with a strong female lead (See: Black Panther, Wonder Woman, RBG, Wow it's tragic that I can't think of any more), and that I could take on the world after a coat of makeup or while wearing some new clothes or a well-coordinated outfit. But the power doesn't come from the products themselves. It comes from the confidence.
I've felt just as great at certain moments where I am working hard and feel focused, or after I turn in a project I worked really hard on. These things aren't limited to my appearance, and they're certainly not linked to my ability to attract men. If my confidence was linked to that, I'd be the most insecure person alive.
But so often girls are thrown the idea that their only source of confidence is men. And since they never see any indication it could come from anywhere else, they never even look anywhere else. They get stuck in this cycle of trying to get and keep a boyfriend. It becomes a constant struggle to be perfect, so that they'll be loved. And out of this, there comes a certain type of guy, too. The guy who claims he wants a girl who can "be herself", but really, he wants a girl who can be dependent on him.
Guys have a whole new ballgame of stereotypes, and if ours is weakness, theirs is strength. The need to constantly be strong, to be needed by others, to become that knight in shining armor.
This is the kind of guy that tells me I look beautiful with my glasses and I don't need to wear contacts. It's where the "Nice Guy" comes from. The guy who says "you're beautiful" one second, and "you're a bitch", the next. They want to be the hero, but they're far too insecure themselves. And they attract these girls who are so deeply insecure who are desperate to be a part of the boyfriend culture. And it's just two really insecure people, leaning desperately on one another to try to fit into the idea of a relationship that the media has fed to them all their lives.
It occurs in different degrees, obviously. It's not one size fits all, but I find that a lot of my generation's insecurity does come from the media. The majority of ads I see, on TV, on YouTube, even on my email, are for makeup, clothes, stereotypical "girly" pursuits. In most movies I watch, the characters that look most like me are shoved off to the side and never developed. In politics I had to watch my country elect the dumbest man alive over a woman who had decades more experience in the political field but was hated because of her husband's decisions. It was painful.
People like to say things have changed, and they ask all the time to "point to an unfair law", or something that's inequitable in our constitution. People can't seem to understand that it's not a legal thing anymore. Now it's a societal thing, and society in this age is shaped by media. Until we change that media, we'll always have boyfriend culture.




"Studies predict that if women stopped buying cosmetic products and services,
Every economy in the world would collapse overnight. 
This is a call to collapse the economy. 
Let's cover our scented tampons in hairspray, light them on fire,
and throw them at Maybelline's headquarters. 
Let's take all our left over lotions and soaps 
and make the world's largest slip 'n slide down Capitol Hill. 
Weight Watchers will have a whole new meaning -
Like, wait and watch while I burn this all down.
Imagine what we could do with all these Spanx?
Probably make some sort of catapult, and launch our skin-softening bath bombs into enemy territory.
Victoria's Secret?
It's that she's going gout of business.
I have picked at my body like a scab,
I have squeezed at my face in the mirror until no more me could come out of me,
I changed my outfit nine times before I got here.
Oh! You thought we were gonna stop at burning bras?
Well then you shouldn't have given us so much flammable stuff. 
Are you gonna put those fake eyelashes on for me?
No?
Then I don't want them!
Does that shampoo also come with the photoshop you used on the model?
No?
Then I don't want it!
Forget you, perfume -
I'd rather not smell like Island Splash or Delicate Blossom,
Because what does that even smell like? That's not even a real scent!
Let's throw out our razors and grow our hair as long as rivers.
How beautiful it will be to take the money I spend to be pretty for you,
make my hair soft for you,
my nails like candy for you,
give myself skin cancer for you,
go under the night for you, 
and stop giving the 76 cents back. 
There were days I spent hours crying in the dressing room,
days I didn't leave the house in case someone had a camera for fear of becoming another before picture.
So thank you, Cosmo, for giving me 472 more beauty tips to completely ignore,
Thank you for all the leftover lipstick to write 'I am flawless' on the wall,
Thank you for the cover of vanishing cream.
Thank you for making us invisible.
That way, you'll never see us coming."
-- SPEAK LIKE A GIRL
(Olivia Gatwood & Megan Falley)

Comments

  1. You brought up so many valid points in this blog and I totally agree with your evaluation of boyfriend culture. I can't go on Instagram for five minutes without seeing some promotion of the idea of having a boyfriend. Sometimes a celebrity posts a picture of her and her S.O., or it could be a meme or video about relationships. It often makes me feel like I am being devoid of the high school or teenage experience simply because I don't have a boyfriend. It makes me feel anxious and almost desperate to pursue finding a S.O. even though I know that this feeling isn't really healthy or reflective of what I want. I also agree that this part of our culture cannot be changed until the media is changed, but I don't see that happening in the foreseeable future. Another possible solution could be to do what you're doing: recognizing the flaws and unrealistic expectations of this culture and being a good influence on your friends to also reject these ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you and Maeve. The boyfriend culture is so, so toxic, but unfortunately, it is so, so prevalent. Boyfriend culture encourages relationships even if they are unhealthy. It encourages both boys and girls to fall into these terrible stereotypes. I am not currently in a relationship, yet I see so much media telling me I should be in one. The media ignores the vast segments of the teenage population who might not feel ready to start dating, or might be single for other reasons. The media only promotes one idea of the teenage experience, and that image always has to include a relationship. Boyfriend culture strips us all down to our S.O.s, as though we are not people in and of ourselves, but we are so much more than who we choose to be with. Why can't the media see that?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I totally agree, Molly. The “boyfriend culture” is an effect gender stereotypes and female oppression that is can be severely detrimental to many young girls. However, I think that quite gradually (maybe a little to slowly) progress is being made. More and more women are choosing to stay single, not get married, etc., which helps to mitigate the harmful social stigma. Sadly, this progress is often inhibited by the media’s portrayal of dating and the highly sexual value that it puts on relationships. Rarely will you see a film featuring a platonic relationship. I’m not saying that platonic relationships are the only good relationships out there, but when almost all movies are so hypersexualized, one cannot be surprised in the least bit to see these expectations rubbing off on society.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Work on Your Lyrics, Rihanna

The 1967 Chevy Impala

vines that cured my anxiety over my term paper